The recent outage of SoundCloud was the result of everybody doing the right thing. This totally jives with John Allspaw’s message that looking for a root cause will lead to you finding smart people simply doing their jobs.
This is what happened.
The technologies at play
The number of interactions that escalated to the outage should be interesting for other Rails/MySQL shops out there. We’re using many idiomatic patterns within Rails that ended up having devastating consequences.
Cache keys that avoid invalidation
It’s best practice to form your cache keys in a way that doesn’t require you to issue cache key deletions, and rather let normal evictions reclaim garbage keys. To do this we use the ‘updated_at’ column on some of our models in the cache key so that if the model updates, we know we’ll get a new key.
ActiveRecord::Timestamp#touch
There is an innocuous method called ‘touch’ that will simply bump the updated_at and save that record. This is quite convenient to call on containers of has_many things like a forum topic is to its posts. With a recent ‘updated_at’ and consistent way to keep that recent via ‘touch’, there is a clean decoupling of cache strategy from business modeling when you intend to communicate the container’s version is as recent as the most recent addition.
ActiveRecord::Associations::BelongsToAssociation :counter_cache
In the absence of indexed expressions and multi index merges that some databases have, MySQL and InnoDB leaves it to the application to keep lookups of counts efficient. When dealing with tables of multiple millions of rows, a simple query like:
select count(*) from things Could take tens of seconds as InnoDB actually needs to traverse all primary keys and literally count the rows that exist which are visible in the current transaction.
class Foo belongs_to :things, :counter_cache => true end Is a simple and convenient workaround to avoid the ‘count(*)’ overhead where when a new Foo is created on a thing, that thing’s ‘foos_count’ would get a database increment by one. When it’s removed, the ‘foos_count’ would be decremented by one.
ActiveRecord::Associations::Association :dependent => :destroy
What better way to maintain all the business rules on deletion than to make sure your model’s callbacks fire when a container is destroyed. When your business consistency is maintained in the ORM, this is also the best place to ensure proper business rules on removal.
This simply does the following for every association:
thing.foos.each(&:destroy) Before:
thing.destroy It’s best to have the behavior declared where the association is declared and let the framework make sure it’s not forgotten when actually performing the destruction.
More than 140 characters
Some of the features of SoundCloud deserve more than 140 characters to do them justice. Even more than 255 characters. The tools that Rails gives you out of the box when you need more than 255 characters on a string in your data layer are limited; you’re left with the ‘text’ type in your schema definition. In MySQL this translates to a “TEXT” column.
A TEXT column with a maximum length of 65,535 (216 - 1) characters. Well, in most cases we wouldn’t need more than 1000 characters for much on our site, but in the spirit of “deployed or it didn’t happen”, our early database schemas were mostly driven by the simplest option that ActiveRecord::Schema offered. (We also have way too many NULLable columns)
Trade space for time or time for space
The early days, SoundCloud ran on 3 servers. CPU was precious so for some of the HTML conversion tasks we traded space for time and are storing a cached version of the HTML for some of the longer text fields in the same row as the record. This was the right choice at the time for the request load and available CPU.
(time is usually easier to scale than space)
Tune your DBs for your workload
We separate reads from writes on our data layer, and we also have slightly different tunings on the DB slaves that accept reads. We also have experienced statement-based asynchronous slave replication breaking the replication thread due to these different tunings on different hardware.
We use row-based (actually mixed) replication between our masters and slaves because it’s as close as you’ll get to the storage engines speaking directly to each other, minimizing the risk of differences in hardware/tuning interfering with the replication thread.
Alert on disk space thresholds
We have a massive amount of Nagios checks on all our systems, including host-based partition %free checks. When any partition on a host reaches a threshold of free space, an alert is sent.
Separate data and write ahead log physical devices
Most OLTP databases have data that is bound by random read/writes, whereas binary logs are fundamentally sequential writes. You want these workloads on different spindles when using rotating disks because a transaction cannot complete without first being written to the binary log. If you need to move the drive head for your binlog, you’ve just added milliseconds to all your transactions.
Clean up after yourself
Periodically there are administrative tasks that need to be performed on the site like mass takedowns of inappropriate content. The Rails console is amazing when you need to work directly with your business domain. Fire it up, get it done. For one-off maintenance tasks this is a life saver.
Add Spam, Mix, Bake and we’ve been Served
This all adds up, reviewing the good parts:
- Abstract away bookkeeping in your domain model
- Leverage existing patterns to get the job done quickly
- Tune and monitor your DBs
- Hand administer your site via your domain model
If you haven’t noticed yet, there have been some incorrigible entrepreneurs using some groups to advertise their pharmaceuticals distribution businesses. They have very thorough descriptions (5-50KB worth), and unprecedented activity with tens to thousands of posts in their own groups.
At 1:00pm yesterday, we were working through our cleanups, and cranked open a console with a large list of confirmed groups to remove. With Rails this is as simple as:
Group.find(ids).each(&:destroy) Looks innocent enough.
What the database sees
From the database perspective all of the automated bookkeeping and business domain extraction of individual destroys creates statements, this ended up looking something like this:
DELETE post
UPDATE group SET posts_count = posts_count - 1
UPDATE group SET updated_at = now()
... x 1-5000
DELETE track_group_contribution
UPDATE group SET tracks_count = tracks_count - 1
UPDATE group SET updated_at = now()
... x 1-5000
DELETE user_group_membership
UPDATE group SET members_count = members_count - 1
UPDATE group SET updated_at = now()
... x 1-5000
So we’re seeing 2N+1 number of updates on a group where N is the sum of associated objects.
What replication sees
When using row-based replication, any change to a row gets that entire row added to the binary log. Some of these groups had over 100k worth of text columns and hundreds of associated posts. When parsing a given binlog, these group updates were taking over 90% of the replication events being sent to the slaves.
What the binlog partition sees
This is what finally brought us down. We were producing over 3GB/min of binlogs to be replicated to our slaves from these many group updates. Our binlog partition filled up from 10GB to 100GB in a matter of 30 minutes.
The MySQL docs are clear about what happens with a full data partition. When data cannot be written, MySQL just waits. The behavior around the binlog partition wasn’t as clear. That last binlog event had a partial write. When the disk filled, the binlog corrupted. When that last event in the last binlog was attempted to be sent to the slaves, it failed and the slaves stopped replicating.
Got fatal error 1236 from master when reading data from binary log:
'log event entry exceeded max_allowed_packet; Increase max_allowed_packet on master' Our max_allowed_packet is big enough for any of our rows.
How we recovered
We had a master with live queries that were not coming back from a ‘killed’ state. We scaled the binlog LVM partition so that it could accommodate new writes now, but the DB was not budging. We had no idea how to get it to start writing again so we began a failover process.
All our slaves were at the same position just before the corrupted event, so we grabbed one, confirmed the tuning was good and then promoted it. We went through the many other slaves and reconfigured them and we were good, consistent to the last event. All we lost were the few processes that were waiting to write to the full partition.
Ironically, 2 of our team members are currently in the datacenter recabling some of our racks. We also have 4 swanky new DB class machines powered on, but we were a day or two away from getting them networked and integrated. We were just short of having that excess capacity to accept the spike in load from return visitors after the tweet “We’re back!”.
Forensics
We tried to understand the cause of the sudden binlog growth so we could safely enable the site without a replay of what just had happened. We expanded out some of the logs with ‘mysqlbinlog –verbose’ to show that it was filled with group spam. To confirm that it was group activity, we compared the replication data volume per table of a well sized binlog file with an abnormally large with the following awk program:
for log in mysql-bin.03980{5..7}; do
mysqlbinlog $log |\
awk '
/Table_map/ { name = $9 }
/BINLOG/ { bytes = 0; col = 1 }
{ if (col) bytes += length($0) }
/\*!\*/ { if (col) sizes[name] += bytes; col = 0 }
END { for (i in sizes) print sizes[i], i }
' |\
sort -n |\
tee /tmp/$log.sizes &
doneThis created a list of byte sizes of base64 encoded row data to table name. Groups took 820MB compared to the next largest table at 30MB.
Put this script in your toolbox, it’s also great to use for getting an idea of which tables are your hottest under normal operations.
We also used our recently finished HDFS-based log aggregation system to run map reduce jobs over our web and app logs to identify any possible abuse vectors around groups that were coming from the outside.
What we learned
When maintenance around abusive usage is also a part of your business, think about the data and impact on your running system for all maintenance work.
Cut your losses early and resist the temptation to find the “root cause” during an outage incident. Failforward. Save what you can for forensics after you’re back up.
Uncleared acknowledged alerts are alertable offenses. A big question during the incident was, “where were the alerts?”. It turned out that the host-based disk space check was previously acknowledged because we had an unrelated partition fill on the same host within expectation. This acknowledgment wasn’t cleared before the binlog partition filled so we didn’t get the 20 minutes of lead time we could have had.
In the heat of the moment, put your heads together, make a plan for the next X minutes, execute, and repeat until you’re back up. All the engineers were at battle stations during this outage. This incident blindsided us and all kinds of theories were thrown around. When we focused on do X within Y minutes we got down to time boxing research to be able to take our next action. This worked very well.
Pay off your technical debt. In the past, we took a loan on the future for trading space for time. Paying off these kinds of debts is easy to defer, until the collector comes to visit. Keep a list of the debts chosen, and the debts discovered. Even without an estimated cost to fix, your debt is a learning tool for others for where and when measured choices towards the road of delivery are made.
Be as specific as you can with your expected data types. We never expected group descriptions to be larger than 2KB. We should have encoded that expectation loud and clear in the data and business layers.
Doing the right thing
We are all working with the best practices in mind, yet the combination of all that we were doing correctly ended up with this outage nobody expected. Yesterday was an incredible learning experience for everyone at SoundCloud, and the entire team joined together with a positive spirit and heartfelt passion to restore service as quickly as possible. I’m quite proud to work with everyone here.
